Best 2 Slice Toaster Under $50 (2026): 4 Picks Worth Buying
In this article
Looking for the Best 2 Slice Toaster Under $50 (2026): 4 Picks Worth Buying You can get good toast without spending much. The catch is that budget toasters differ a lot in heat, shade control and how well they handle bagels.
We compared four cheap 2 slice toasters using independent hands-on tests and published specs. We don’t test toasters ourselves, and we will show you exactly where our facts come from. Below you will find a quick answer, a comparison table, short reviews and a simple buying guide.
Key Takeaways
For most people, the Cuisinart Classic Metal 2-Slice (CPT-160P1) is the best 2 slice toaster under $50. It has six shade settings and bagel, defrost and reheat presets. If you want to spend less, choose the Hamilton Beach 22794. Both have 1.5-inch slots for bagels. On any model, avoid the highest shade settings, which burned toast or set off smoke alarms in the tests we read.
Best 2 Slice Toasters Under $50: Top Picks
- Best overall: Cuisinart Classic Metal 2-Slice (CPT-160P1). Most settings and presets. [Check Price on Amazon]([AMAZON LINK])
- Best value: Hamilton Beach 22794. Seven settings, toast boost and auto-shutoff. [Check Price on Amazon]([AMAZON LINK])
- Best no-frills pick: Black+Decker T2569B. Simple, extra-wide slots, strong budget reputation. [Check Price on Amazon]([AMAZON LINK])
- Best for small counters: Bella 2 Slice Slim. Under 4 inches wide. [Check Price on Amazon]([AMAZON LINK])
Prices change often. We only list models that were in the budget range in the sources we read, so always check the current price before you buy.
- Dimensions:23.6 X 33.9 X 23.8 inches
- Capacity:16 place settings
- Number of cycles:6
- Warranty:1-year limited
More features: touch control technology, EasyGlide rack
How the Four Toasters Compare
| Toaster | Best for | Slot width | Shade settings | Presets | Standout |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cuisinart CPT-160P1 | Best overall | 1.5 in | 6 | Bagel, defrost, reheat | 3-year warranty |
| Hamilton Beach 22794 | Best value | 1.5 in | 7 | Bagel, defrost | Toast boost, auto-shutoff |
| Black+Decker T2569B | No-frills toast | Extra-wide [CHECK LISTING] | [CHECK LISTING] | [CHECK LISTING] | TechGearLab budget pick |
| Bella 2 Slice Slim | Small counters | [CHECK LISTING] | 6 | [CHECK LISTING] | Under 4 in wide |
Heat and smoke alarm notes (our summary of published tests)
We pulled the heat and smoke notes from Yahoo Shopping’s hands-on test into one table. Competitor reviews list these facts in separate paragraphs, which makes them hard to compare.
| Toaster | Outside after toasting | Smoke alarm trigger |
|---|---|---|
| Cuisinart CPT-160P1 | Hot, not unsafe | No |
| Hamilton Beach 22794 | Hot, not unsafe | Yes, on the highest setting |
| Black+Decker T2569B | Hot, not scorching | Yes, on the sixth setting |
| Bella 2 Slice Slim | Warm but touchable | Not reported |
Our Best 2 Slice Toaster Reviews
Best overall: Cuisinart Classic Metal 2-Slice Toaster (CPT-160P1)
This is the toaster to buy if you want one model that handles bread, bagels and frozen items well. In Yahoo Shopping’s test of nine toasters, it earned the top spot for even browning and a good range of shade levels.
Quick specs
- Power: 900 watts
- Slots: two, 1.5 inches wide
- Shade settings: 6
- Presets: bagel, defrost, reheat, plus cancel
- Finish: brushed stainless steel
- Warranty: 3 years
- Size: [CHECK LISTING]
Key features
- Three presets handle bagels, frozen bread and leftovers without guesswork.
- Six shade levels step up gradually, so you can find a favorite.
- 1.5-inch slots fit thick bagels.
- Slide-out crumb tray and cord wrap make cleanup and storage easy.
Why it’s our pick: It gave the widest range of toast colors in the test, and each step looked different from the last. The three-year warranty is good coverage for a budget toaster.
Pros: even color range, useful presets, easy cleanup, 3-year warranty. Cons: the outside gets hot, the finish shows fingerprints, and frozen waffles needed a higher setting than expected.
Who it’s for: people who toast Best 2 Slice Toaster Under $50? Who should skip it: families with young children, because of the hot exterior. Price tier: $$ (upper end of the under-$50 range)
Claim vs. reality: Six shade settings sounds like a lot, but the lightest setting barely browned the bread in the test. Plan on using the middle of the dial.
[IMAGE: Canva spec card for the Cuisinart. Alt: “Cuisinart CPT-160P1 2 slice toaster specs”]
[Check Price on Amazon]([AMAZON LINK])
Best value: Hamilton Beach 22794 Two-Slice Toaster
If you want the lowest cost without giving up the basics, this is the best cheap toaster of the four. Yahoo Shopping named it the best budget toaster in its test.
Quick specs
- Power: 850 watts
- Slots: two, 1.5 inches wide
- Shade settings: 7
- Presets: bagel, defrost
- Finish: stainless steel
- Extras: toast boost, auto-shutoff, slide-out crumb tray
Key features
- Toast boost lifts small items higher so you can grab them easily.
- Auto-shutoff turns the toaster off at the end of each cycle, even if toast gets stuck.
- Seven shade settings give you room to adjust.
- Compact, lightweight body is easy to move.
Why it’s our pick: It covers the essentials at a lower cost than the Cuisinart. In the test, Pop-Tarts came out warm and gooey, and the bagel was chewy inside.
Pros: low cost, safety shutoff, handy toast boost, easy cleanup. Cons: the outside gets hot, it has fewer presets (no reheat), and the highest setting set off the tester’s smoke detector.
Who it’s for: first apartments, guest rooms, and anyone on a tight budget. Who should skip it: anyone who wants a reheat button or a cooler outside. Price tier: $
Claim vs. reality: Seven settings look generous, yet the tester found only three or four of them gave toast worth eating. Frozen waffles also needed setting two or three.
[IMAGE: Canva spec card. Alt: “Hamilton Beach 22794 2 slice toaster features”]
[Check Price on Amazon]([AMAZON LINK])
Best no-frills pick: Black+Decker 2-Slice Toaster (T2569B)
Choose this one if you just want toast, not extras. TechGearLab named it the best budget toaster in its tests, saying it scored close to a Breville model that costs about five times as much.
Quick specs
- Slots: extra-wide [CHECK LISTING]
- Shade settings: [CHECK LISTING]
- Power: [CHECK LISTING]
- Presets: [CHECK LISTING]
Key features
- Roomy slots per Yahoo Shopping’s tester.
- Simple controls with nothing to learn.
- Lightweight body is easy to store.
Why it’s our pick: A basic toaster that makes good everyday toast is all many people need, and this one has a strong reputation for that.
Pros: low cost, simple, roomy slots, strong budget reviews. Cons: only the two lowest shades looked best in Yahoo’s test, the sixth setting set off a smoke detector, and the tester preferred the Hamilton Beach for Pop-Tarts and bagels.
Who it’s for: students, offices and anyone who wants plain toast. Who should skip it: people who want bagel or defrost modes (confirm on the listing). Price tier: $
Claim vs. reality: TechGearLab’s “same toast for a fifth of the price” shows that basic toasting does not get much better as you spend more. Extra money mostly buys features and looks.
[IMAGE: Canva spec card. Alt: “Black+Decker T2569B budget 2 slice toaster”]
[Check Price on Amazon]([AMAZON LINK])
Best for small counters: Bella 2 Slice Slim Toaster
This is the best 2 slice toaster under $50 for tight spaces. In Yahoo Shopping’s test, it was the narrowest of the toasters, at under four inches wide.
Quick specs
- Width: under 4 inches
- Shade settings: 6
- Shell: coated, in five colors
- Power: [CHECK LISTING]
- Presets: [CHECK LISTING]
Key features
- Slim body fits narrow counters and shelves.
- Very light, so it’s easy to move.
- Cooler shell: warm after toasting, but the tester could still touch it.
- Color choices help it blend in.
Why it’s our pick: It solves one problem well: a small kitchen.Best 2 Slice Toaster Under $50, The cooler shell is also a plus for homes with kids.
Pros: slim, light, cooler shell, colors. Cons: the lowest setting gave very pale toast, bagels came out less toasty than on the Hamilton Beach, and its slots are slightly less roomy.
Who it’s for: dorms, small apartments and tight counters. Who should skip it: bagel lovers who want roomy slots. Price tier: $
Claim vs. reality: “Slim” means the slots are narrower too. Thick bagels and bakery bread may feel snug.
[Check Price on Amazon]([AMAZON LINK])
Also considered
The Beautiful by Drew Barrymore two-slice toaster got praise from Consumer Reports as a budget-friendly performer, and Yahoo Shopping named it its touchscreen pick. We left it out because the listings we found were at Walmart, and this guide focuses on models you can find on Amazon.
[INTERNAL LINK: our guide to the best 4 slice toaster]
How to Choose a Cheap 2 Slice Toaster
How many shade settings does a toaster really need?
Six or seven is typical, and more numbers do not mean better toast. Yahoo Shopping’s tester found that each number took a different amount of time on different models, and the top levels often burned bread. Judge a toaster by how many of its settings make good toast, not by the count.
When you read reviews, look for comments about the lowest and middle settings. Those are the ones you will use every day. If reviewers say the lightest setting does nothing, plan on starting higher.
Do you need 1.5-inch slots?
Yes, if you toast bagels or thick bread. Yahoo Shopping suggests slots at least 1.5 inches wide for bagels and Texas toast. The Cuisinart and the Hamilton Beach both meet that.Best 2 Slice Toaster Under $50?
Slim toasters trade slot room for a smaller footprint. If you mostly toast sandwich bread, that trade is fine. For bakery loaves and big bagels, pick a wider slot.
Is stainless steel safer to touch than plastic?
No. In the tests we read, several stainless models got hot on the outside. Yahoo’s tester found the Cuisinart and Hamilton Beach hot but not unsafe, while a Saveur toaster guide notes that plastic casings tend to stay cooler, even if they look less premium.
Think about who is in your kitchen. With young kids around, a cooler shell, like the Bella’s coated one, may matter more than a metal look.
How much electricity does a 2 slice toaster use?
Very little. A typical cycle costs less than one cent. This is our own estimate, not a tested number. A 900-watt toaster running for three minutes uses about 0.045 kWh. At 17 cents per kWh (check your own rate), that is under one cent per cycle.Best 2 Slice Toaster Under $50?
Two cycles a day add up to about $5 to $6 a year. Wattage on these picks ranges from 850 to 900 watts in the sources we used, so the difference between them is tiny. In the US, all of these plug into a standard 120-volt outlet.Best 2 Slice Toaster Under $50?
How We Research
We don’t test toasters ourselves. We build these guides from other people’s careful testing, and we show our sources.Best 2 Slice Toaster Under $50?
- Hands-on test reports: Yahoo Shopping’s test of nine toasters (updated June 2026) and TechGearLab’s toaster tests.
- Testing method context: Consumer Reports scores every slice against an industry toast-color chart across 113 models.
- Specs: published specs as reported in those reviews and on product listings.
- Owner reviews: [ADD: number of Amazon reviews you read and the date, or delete this line]
- Our own math: the electricity estimate above.Best 2 Slice Toaster Under $50?
How we picked: Every toaster here is a 2-slice model, was in the budget range in our sources, appeared in at least one independent hands-on test, and can be found on Amazon. We update this guide every few months.
Best 2 Slice Toaster Under $50: FAQ
Is a $50 toaster good enough?
Yes, for everyday toast. Independent tests found budget models that toast as evenly as pricier ones. You pay extra mostly for looks, extra presets and special features.
Can cheap toasters handle bagels and frozen waffles?
Yes, if you choose the right slots and settings. Look for 1.5-inch slots and a bagel preset. In Yahoo’s test, frozen waffles needed a higher setting on several budget models, so start at the middle and adjust.Best 2 Slice Toaster Under $50?
Why does my toaster set off the smoke alarm?
Usually because of a high shade setting or built-up crumbs. Several toasters in the tests triggered smoke detectors on their top settings. Use a lower setting and empty the crumb tray regularly.
When should I replace my toaster?
Replace it if you see rust, fraying cords, sparks, a lasting burning smell, or toast that has become uneven. Yahoo’s guide lists these as warning signs.
Should I get a 2-slice or 4-slice toaster?
A 2-slice is enough for one or two people. A 4-slice suits bigger families and hosting, but it takes more counter space.Best 2 Slice Toaster Under $50?
Should I buy a toaster or a toaster oven?
Buy a toaster if you mostly make toast, bagels and waffles. Choose a toaster oven if you also want to reheat leftovers or make sandwiches.
[INTERNAL LINK: toaster vs toaster oven guide]
Final Thoughts
The best 2 slice toaster under $50 for most people is the Cuisinart CPT-160P1 for its presets and range. The Hamilton Beach 22794 is the best cheap toaster if cost matters most. Pick the Black+Decker for plain toast and the Bella if counter space is tight.
Whichever you choose, start with a middle setting and skip the highest ones. Check the current price on Amazon before you buy.Best 2 Slice Toaster Under $50?
Affiliate disclosure: We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. This does not affect which products we recommend.
About the author: [Asaduzzaman Nayem], [one or two lines about you and why you research kitchen products].
